Home › Forums › Clinical Practice › CRP, adipose tissue, and the “obesity is a disease” claim — what are we actually concluding?
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
January 30, 2026 at 1:21 pm #1847
Monica Peralta
Hi everyone,
I’d love to open a discussion on a common argument I keep seeing in weight-centric spaces: that elevated CRP in higher-weight individuals is “evidence” that obesity is a chronic inflammatory disease.
A few points Dr Katarina Wind and I, kept coming back to, and I’m curious how others here think about this:
1) CRP is not weight-specific.
People across the weight spectrum can have elevated CRP, and people at higher weights can have normal CRP. Adipose tissue is also something everyone needs for survival — so inflammation markers shouldn’t automatically be framed as a pathology of body size.2) Metabolic heterogeneity matters.
There are studies describing higher-weight individuals with normal CRP and favorable cardiometabolic profiles (“metabolically healthy obesity”). In a weight-neutral paradigm, the question becomes: what protects these individuals? Rather than assuming all larger bodies require shrinking.3) Even if CRP is elevated, weight loss is not a neutral or reliable intervention.
Given the long-term inefficacy of intentional weight loss for most people — and the documented harms of weight cycling and stigma — “weight loss as treatment” is not an evidence-based default response to an inflammatory biomarker.4) Biomarkers ≠ clinical outcomes.
We have to be extremely cautious about moving from lab or mechanistic findings (e.g., inflammatory signaling in adipocytes) to broad clinical prescriptions. Elevated CRP does not automatically translate into meaningful differences in outcomes, and lowering a biomarker is not the same as improving health or reducing morbidity.How do you respond when colleagues equate CRP elevation with “proof” that obesity itself is a disease?
Are there papers, frameworks, or teaching language you’ve found especially helpful for distinguishing association from causation — and biomarkers from outcomes?Would love any thoughts or references from this community.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.