Home › Forums › Clinical Practice › Pediatrics advice › Reply To: Pediatrics advice
Hi, Mara. Thanks for your patience as I dig out of an email deluge. I didn’t want to miss this conversation!
A few thoughts as a pediatrician who has shifted from primarily “prescription for movement, prescription for food, etc” eat less/move more approaches to now focusing on whole family emotional & relationship-centered health in primarily nonclinical education & coaching programs. The main points are not targeting weight as a goal (especially not another’s weight, like a child’s), understanding emotions & stress management, foster relationships, and ED prevention.
1) Yes, your patients & their families will approach primary care with a weight-loss centric framework. That is our culture. In order to change it, I acknowledge what is, how it is harmful, and how everything we are talking about is part of changing the culture. I offer reminders that culture is changed/unlearned with practice. I call it out all the time that we are changing the conversation right here, right now.
** Don’t be afraid to ask parents about their concerns with weight – it’s often not about the child, it’s about wanting to prevent the child from going down a path the parent knows well – whether it is bullying, diets, ED, over-exercise. The focus on kids’ weight all goes through the parents (IMHO), so knowing the reason for their focus is immensely helpful to connect with them. Parents readily acknowledge how the weight-loss-focus has been harmful to them and it totally opens the conversation to creating change for their kids.
2) In clinic, I simply ask, “What concerns do you have about your child’s growth or development?” when I start a visit. Put it all on the table – and that’s when the questions usually come up. With adolescents, I ask if there are parts of their body that they are concerned about or think should be different. No assumptions on my end – and then let them drive.
3) I do not define health by weight. I’ve been writing blogs about this and offering more clarity in the message as I’ve refined it over time (again, note work in progress as far as my own unlearning of indoctrination about weight = health). I point out that it’s ridiculous how we savor the infant with full thighs, only to be focused on those same thighs after the child is a few years old. Pointing out the contradictions has been helpful to welcome families to see differently without me having to push on the education. (eg, “Isn’t it CRAZY how we celebrate chunky infants with all the rolls in the first year, but now as soon as they’re 2, folks are telling them to cut back?”)
When being asked about helping kids lose weight, I use the iceberg analogy all the time: we’re focusing on the wrong thing. Weight isn’t a selection/dial/catalog of options.
4) I am always shifting focus to how diets, weight loss-focus are about restriction, cutting back and shame. Cutting back and will power get exhausted. Instead, what do they want MORE of? This is where the conversation shifts to: more movement, more time together, (often less pushback or fights, but I can’t argue with that!), more sleep… it’s a great shift to focus on the behavioral aspects that they can focus on, and it applies to the whole family.
A sign in my primary care office says it all: “Shame doesn’t make anyone healthier.”
Happy to be of support.
Wendy Schofer, MD