Home › Forums › Clinical Practice › Pediatrics advice

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1224
    Mara Gordon

      Hi everyone,

      I’m curious to hear advice from the group about weight inclusive care for children, in general. I’m a family doctor in general academic practice, and the vast majority of my patients approach primary care with a weight-loss centric framework.

      I’ve gotten way better at these conversations with adults, but still struggle with kids!

      Typical questions include:

      Is my child a healthy weight?

      How can I help my child lose weight?

      Is she too big?

      Ranging from toddlers to teens! It breaks my heart.

      I’d love to hear from the group how you approach size-inclusive well child care.

      (For the purposes of this post, I’m mostly talking about well child care — NOT kids with hypertension or diabetes, etc… Although would love to discuss those topics, as well!)

      Thanks. Looking forward to learning from this wise group.

       

       

      Mara Gordon, MD (she/her)

      MaraGordonMD.substack.com

      #1238
      Anonymous

        Hi Mara, I’m still learning the AWSIM message board so hopefully this reply reaches you.

        These are topics that we are discussing as a group at Seattle Children’s. I’d be happy to set up a conversation to dive deeper into this if you’re interested.

        I’m also going to reach out to Lisa E. to see if there is interest opportunity for Peds focused case discussions.

        Robyn Evans, ARNP

        Pronouns she/her

        Clinical Lead, Eating Disorders | Adolescent Medicine

        Nursing Faculty – Leadership Education in Adolescent Health Fellowship

        Seattle Children’s Hospital

        206-987-2028
        OFFICE

        206-987-8317 Confidential Voicemail

        206-987-4414
        ADMIN

        206-985-3499
        FAX

        Robyn.Evans@seattlechildrens.org

        OFFICE 4540 Sand Point Way NE, Suite 200, Seattle, WA 98105

        MAIL M/S CSB-200, PO Box 5371, Seattle, WA 98145-5005

        WWW seattlechildrens.org

        CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information protected by law. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited.
        If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message.

        #1239
        Shannon Minnehan

          Hi Mara,

          Sorry for the slow response. This breaks my heart as well, and it is something I find comes up daily in my practice (though I am on the mental health side of medicine). I feel moving the needle with pediatrics starts with the parents, of course, but also with pediatricians, and hence all medical education.

          Some of these things have been helpful for me:

          I have a personal story to tell regarding the harm of weight centric care for children, so I tell it.

          Framing the conversation around recent research findings which clearly show that bodies of all sizes are healthy and that health is defined in many different ways. “All Bodies are Good Bodies”– I have many stickers in my office to prove this 🙂

          Dieting and restriction of food are strong risk factors for eating disorders (which have around 9% lifetime prevalence)

          I also sometimes reference this Poodle science video as it logical for many audiences-

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H89QQfXtc-k

          “You can best support your child’s development by modeling a healthy perspective around food and all bodies. Society will always find a way to tell them how to look a certain way. Medical providers will not do this, we will teach you to have peace with your body”

          Just my perspective, I find it coming out on repeat some days.
          Shannon

          #1240
          Shannon Minnehan

            Addendum– of course the last sentence is far from true, just my wishful mantra!

            #1242
            Mara Gordon

              Thank you so much! I’d love to hear about your group and how you’re navigating these issues — please keep me posted.

              #1244
              Wendy Schofer

                Hi, Mara. Thanks for your patience as I dig out of an email deluge. I didn’t want to miss this conversation!

                A few thoughts as a pediatrician who has shifted from primarily “prescription for movement, prescription for food, etc” eat less/move more approaches to now focusing on whole family emotional & relationship-centered health in primarily nonclinical education & coaching programs. The main points are not targeting weight as a goal (especially not another’s weight, like a child’s), understanding emotions & stress management, foster relationships, and ED prevention.

                1) Yes, your patients & their families will approach primary care with a weight-loss centric framework. That is our culture. In order to change it, I acknowledge what is, how it is harmful, and how everything we are talking about is part of changing the culture. I offer reminders that culture is changed/unlearned with practice. I call it out all the time that we are changing the conversation right here, right now.

                ** Don’t be afraid to ask parents about their concerns with weight – it’s often not about the child, it’s about wanting to prevent the child from going down a path the parent knows well – whether it is bullying, diets, ED, over-exercise. The focus on kids’ weight all goes through the parents (IMHO), so knowing the reason for their focus is immensely helpful to connect with them. Parents readily acknowledge how the weight-loss-focus has been harmful to them and it totally opens the conversation to creating change for their kids.

                2) In clinic, I simply ask, “What concerns do you have about your child’s growth or development?” when I start a visit. Put it all on the table – and that’s when the questions usually come up. With adolescents, I ask if there are parts of their body that they are concerned about or think should be different. No assumptions on my end – and then let them drive.

                3) I do not define health by weight. I’ve been writing blogs about this and offering more clarity in the message as I’ve refined it over time (again, note work in progress as far as my own unlearning of indoctrination about weight = health). I point out that it’s ridiculous how we savor the infant with full thighs, only to be focused on those same thighs after the child is a few years old. Pointing out the contradictions has been helpful to welcome families to see differently without me having to push on the education. (eg, “Isn’t it CRAZY how we celebrate chunky infants with all the rolls in the first year, but now as soon as they’re 2, folks are telling them to cut back?”)

                When being asked about helping kids lose weight, I use the iceberg analogy all the time: we’re focusing on the wrong thing. Weight isn’t a selection/dial/catalog of options.

                4) I am always shifting focus to how diets, weight loss-focus are about restriction, cutting back and shame. Cutting back and will power get exhausted. Instead, what do they want MORE of? This is where the conversation shifts to: more movement, more time together, (often less pushback or fights, but I can’t argue with that!), more sleep… it’s a great shift to focus on the behavioral aspects that they can focus on, and it applies to the whole family.

                A sign in my primary care office says it all: “Shame doesn’t make anyone healthier.”

                Happy to be of support.

                Wendy Schofer, MD

                http://www.wendyschofermd.com

                #1245
                Sarah Halter

                  I really love Wendy’s contribution, especially point #4. I’ve been trying to do this more in both my pediatric patients and adults – I encourage patients to pivot their thought process so that it’s not “what can we restrict, what can we take away” but “what can we ADD?” This helps me lead into into a discussion about how to add fruits and veggies in our regular daily diet or include joyful movement because it’s fun and good for our muscles.

                  Anyway, just my 2 cents.

                  #1247
                  Taka Yamuguchi

                    Hi Mara,

                    Everyone here is so thoughtful and creative. I agree Wendy has made some great points. I love that “shame doesn’t make anyone healthier” sign– I’m going to borrow that!

                    #1 is a really good one here–especially for school-age kids, a primary motivation for a parent’s concern about weight is being fearful of how other kids or society will treat them. Of course, this often comes with a parent’s own baggage and childhood trauma around body shaming. In the limited time we have as PCPs, I think we try to detach and refocus the primary concern of, say, bullying, from the secondary concern of weight gain. I always try and focus on body safety–make it clear that it’s my biggest concern and even let myself get a bit angry here–it is NOT OK for anyone to be saying unwanted things about your body. That’s the problem, full stop. And then it’s the related conversation about self-esteem and body image…anyone else have any specific tips for this conversation?

                    If it’s a concern about “being healthy,” then the conversation changes gears a bit toward, as Wendy suggests, what does it mean to be healthy? What can we be doing more of, because it’s fun, not because you’re supposed to.

                    #2 is good for adolescents. I personally think that for adolescents, perhaps my most important job as a pediatrician is to instill self empowerment while instilling trust in reliable sources who are looking out for them. If there are “weight concerns” on the part of the adolescent, ignoring them is not helpful. If the kid is lucky, they have had a variety of voices telling them different things about weight and health. If not, then they are already mired in the diet culture we exist in, whether from family members or social media or any number of things.

                    You as a healthcare authority telling them that it’s OK not to be dieting (or, as often comes up, actively bad to be dieting) or even OK to be happy with your body counts for something, even if they don’t believe you or roll their eyes or what have you. You are one among many people in their lives, and just as adults who’ve struggled with eating disorders often speak to one negative health care encounter that triggered their symptoms, I hope (or at least tell myself) that if I do this hundreds of times, one of them has got to stick.

                    A specific sub-category of this among many of my patients is that as many adolescents are struggling with mental health and isolation and general “blah”-ness, their eating becomes disordered, their activity levels or even leaving-the-house levels drop precariously, and they gain weight. And so depending on where the kid is at, or whether it has already come up, I’ll try to make a light-hearted statement like, “just so you know, I’m talking to you about this because I think you’re a cool kid who deserves to have fun, not because you have stretch marks now.”

                    -Taka Yamaguchi, primary care in MA

                    #1248
                    Mara Gordon
                      Amazing — thank you all for these great suggestions.I had a realization about weight concerns in well child care the other day: I asked the parent to schedule a telehealth visit AFTER the well child visit so we could talk about their weight concerns without the child present. Hopefully, Congress will allow us all in the US to continue with telehealth — I find it’s often useful for purposes like this one. This doesn’t solve the myriad challenges of weight stigma and obesity focus in pediatrics, but at least allows me to talk openly with the parent without worrying how the child perceives it. 
                    Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.