Home › Forums › AWSIM Member Forum › Participate and compromise or backout?

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1257
    Stephanie Griffith

      Hi All
      I sent this message to Lisa earlier who inspired me to post here
      (apologies for the excessive use of the “o” word, just using it based on how its being used in this project)
      I am working with a group from Washington State University to get the ACP Obesity grant to improve education around obesity. I’m really struggling because on the one hand, I think having my perspective on projects like this may help with the direction it takes. On the other hand, the first task was to review the ACP obesity modules which we will likely use as part of the project, which immediately approach obesity as something to be prevented and intervened upon and prevented. It is horribly triggering and I immediately feel like anything I have to add will be light years away from what everyone else thinks constitutes inclusive care. I want to give up and back out- but I wonder if I need to just do my best to make something better than what it would have been if I weren’t involved at all.

      It feels like a big opportunity (we will be developing interdisciplinary case based learning activities) but I know it will be weight centric and anti-fat, even with my input.

      Do you have any guidance?

      #1258
      Ragen Chastain

        Hi Stephanie,

        I’m so sorry that you are put in this position and grateful for the work that you are doing. I want to start by saying that I support whatever you decide to do. I try to approach situations like this from a harm reduction standpoint with the goal that I reduce as much harm as I possibly can and that I speak out in other ways when I can’t. That said, it’s also reasonable to decide that you can’t have an impact that would make it worth putting yourself though it. Again, I support however you decide to handle this and if I can be of any help please don’t hesitate to reach out.

        ~Ragen

        ragen@weightandhealthcare.com

        #1259
        Sarah Halter

          Oh, Stephanie, that’s so tough!

          I want to give you props for wanting to be involved and do something that brings change. I also want to ask if you think you have the bandwidth for this right now?

          Gosh, I think you have to weigh the risk versus benefit. Sure, in a perfect world you would work from within and help change people’s perspectives. Maybe you could only make a small change, but that small change might be worth it. On the other hand, if you think it’s very unlikely your input is going to change anything AND this is going to exhaust you in your personal and professional life, is it really worth it?

          Is there anyone in a leadership position for this project you feel comfortable approaching with your concerns?

          #1283
          Aimée Wattiaux (“ay-MAY”)

            Hi Stephanie,

            I’ve been placed in similar tricky positions. When I know “don’t make it about weight” won’t be a palatable piece of feedback, I try to emphasize the importance of always asking permission before talking about weight, nutrition, or movement, and being quick to pivot if patients don’t seem interested. While I believe everyone would benefit from a weight inclusive approach, I try to emphasize that some people may benefit from a weight inclusive approach / that some people may be actively harmed by a focus on weight.

            Curious what other harm reduction strategies people use in situations like these?

            Aimée

            #1294
            Mara Gordon

              Aimée: I totally agree. One of my talking points with colleagues who
              aren’t fully on-board with a BMI-agnostic approach is to emphasize
              that a weight focus can cause harm. These colleagues may insist that
              striving for a BMe weI <26 is in the patient’s best interest, but
              they’re usually open to the idea that a clinician focus on weight can
              cause harm.
              Then we can have a fruitful conversation about risks vs. benefits of
              clinician-initiated weight loss discussions: there *may* be a benefit
              to weight loss, but there *may* also be significant harm in pushing
              weight loss.
              Stephanie: If you do choose to be involved with the grant, I wonder if
              helping colleagues understand the downsides of weight stigma and
              weight-centric health care might be a helpful area to focus on? In my
              experience, that’s been an easier entry point rather than trying to
              argue about the relationship between BMI and risk of various diseases
              (which, frankly, I don’t think anyone fully understands — even the
              epidemiologists).
              Hope this helps!
              Mara
              Mara Gordon, MD (she/her)
              MaraGordonMD.com
              Chief Complaint on Substack

              #1304
              Lisa Erlanger

                I love this discussion! It’s something I’ve struggled with a lot. I think about your question in two parts-1. Can you do good as part of the group, even if it remains very weight centric? YES. There is so much harm reduction to be done. So many fat patients would be grateful for accessible spaces, appropriately sized equipment, the option not to be weighed, a focus on the chief complaint with the option of “what would be offered to someone smaller,” and permission to discuss weight loss. I’ve also found that so much harm reduction can be done with language and images- removing “heat maps,” “headless fatties,” pictures of fat people eating fast food and looking ill, wording like “afflicted by” “suffering from” “burdened” and references to the cost of obesity. I’ve edited and inserted words that I think make a big difference in offensiveness of curricula, and hopefully make it less triggering. 2. Do you want to be involved? This also has two parts.First, Is it the right thing for your wellbeing? It’s ok not to take on every challenge. Especially if you live in a lager body or have a history of eating disorder or medical trauma, your wellbeing is essential to ongoing work. Some people love the challenge of this kind of thing. For me, it’s really exhausting and triggering and I can’t do much of it. Secondly, do you want your name associated with a project that will be “o” focused in the end, even if you have made it better? You may want to ask to be the “weight stigma consultant” or “sensitivity reader.” This makes your role clear and builds that aspect of your CV. Thanks for starting this conversation and for the work you do!!!I think you had your meeting. How did it go??

                Lisa
                Sent from my iPhone
                #1318
                Glenna Martin

                  Stephanie – SO proud of you! Would love to hear how this went!

                Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.